News →

PolitiFact Virginia: Scott Rates "True" on Minimum Wage Housing Claim

Politifact - Bobby Scott

Speaker: Bobby Scott

Statement: “Studies show at the minimum wage, you can’t rent a two-bedroom apartment anywhere in the United States...a modest, two-bedroom apartment.”

Date: July 15

Setting: House committee hearing

U.S. Rep. Bobby Scott, D-3rd, recently shepherded a bill to raise the minimum wage through the House of Representatives, saying the wage won’t pay for modest housing.

“The studies show at the minimum wage today, you can’t rent a two-bedroom apartment anywhere in the United States,” he told the House Rules Committee on July 15. “I’m not talking about San Francisco or New York City, I’m talking about anywhere - a modest two-bedroom apartment.”

Scott made the claim three times during a five-minute speech to the panel. We checked if he was right.

Stephanie Lalle, Scott’s deputy communications director, said the congressman was referring to a 2019 study by the National Low Income Housing Coalition titled "Out of Reach." The report, updated yearly, examines the affordability of housing for minimum wage earners in more than 3,500 counties and metropolitan areas across the country.

The study found, “In no state, metropolitan area, or county in the U.S. can a worker earning the federal or prevailing state minimum wage afford a modest two-bedroom rental home at fair market rent by working a standard 40-hour workweek.”

There are a few terms we need to break down:

The federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour has been in effect since 2009. Twenty-one states, including Virginia, use that rate as their minimum wage. The rest, and the District of Columbia have set their minimum wage higher. Scott’s bill, which faces a tough road in the U.S. Senate, would gradually increase the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour by 2025.

The prevailing minimum wage is the baseline pay rate that’s in effect in a state or locality. Twenty-nine states exceed the federal minimum, from $7.50 an hour in New Mexico to $12 in California and Washington. Some cities have minimum wages higher than their states. The study used the prevailing minimum wage in its computations for each locality.

Fair market rent is the 40th median percentile of rents (including utilities, but not telephone) paid by tenants who have moved in a locality during the last two years. It’s slightly less than median rent. It is a term used by the federal government in some housing programs and the bottom rent for what the study calls a “modest” home.

The national coalition defines "affordability" as a federal standard that no more than 30% of a household’s gross income should be spent on rent and utilities. That’s the guideline used by the Department of Housing and Urban Development.

So, what the study found is that there is no U.S. locality where minimum wage earners, working 40 hours a week, can find a modest two-bedroom home that will rent for 30% or less of their gross income. In every locality, at least 60% of the two-bedroom units are unaffordable, according to standard housing definitions. In most places, far more than 60% are beyond their means.

In Virginia, for example, a household would have to work 128 hours a week at the state’s minimum wage - or 3.2 full-time jobs - to afford a two-bedroom home at the 40th rent percentile, according to the report. That's third-highest in the nation, trailing Hawaii (3.6), and New Jersey (3.3).

In Richmond, Chesterfield and Henrico, a household would need to work 2.8 full-time jobs at minimum wage to afford the apartment.

The study does not say no two-bedroom home would be available to a minimum-wage earner anywhere in the country. The qualifier “modest” home - used in the report and by Scott - is important. There might be affordable two-bedroom apartments available, but they would be below the “modest” standard - usually, far below..

What about a one-bedroom home? A minimum wage earner would find them affordable in only 28 counties across the country, or less than 1% of the jurisdictions, according to the study.

Several housing experts have told PolitiFact National the coalition’s report is generally consistent with other housing studies, including a recent report published by the Joint Center of Housing Studies and Harvard University.

PolitiFact National cited the coalition’s report last year in fact-checking a statement by U.S. Sen. Kamala Harris, D-Calif, that, “In 99% of counties in America, someone making the minimum wage working full time can’t afford a 1-bedroom apartment." Her claim was rated Mostly True. It was slightly downgraded because she didn’t specify the statistic applied to “modest” homes.

Scott didn’t make that mistake.

Our Ruling

Scott said, “The studies show at the minimum wage today, you can’t rent a two-bedroom apartment anywhere in the United States. I’m not talking about San Francisco or New York City, I’m talking about anywhere - a modest two-bedroom apartment.”

He was referring to annual studies by the National Low Income Housing Coalition that have found there is no U.S. locality where a minimum wage earner, working 40 hours a week, can find a “modest” two-bedroom home that will rent for 30% or less of his gross income.

Scott accurately describes the findings and makes the key distinction that the results don’t apply to all apartments; just those statistically defined as “modest.”

We rate his statement True.

Sources

U.S. Rep, Bobby Scott, Testimony to the House Rules Committee , July 15, 2019 (1:47:15 mark).

PolitiFact, “ Is housing unaffordable for full-time minimum-wage workers in 99% of the counties in America? ” July 19, 2018.

Scott, “ Chairman Scott statement on shameful minimum-wage milestone ,” June 17, 2019.

Labor Law Center, “ State and federal minimum wage rates ,” 2019.

Congress.gov, H,R, 582 , accessed July 26, 2019.

Email from Stephanie Lalle, Deputy communications director for Scott, July 18, 2019.

National Low Income Housing Coalition, “ Out of Reach ,” 2019, 2018.