PolitiFact Virginia: Jones "Half True" on Medicaid Expansion Claim
Speaker: Chis Jones
Statement: Says he “led the fight to expand Medicaid.”
Date: Aug. 18
Setting: TV campaign ad
Del. Chris Jones, R-Suffolk, is introducing himself to voters in his newly-redrawn district as the champion of Medicaid expansion in Virginia. The Democratic Party of Virginia says his claim is bogus.
Jones, the powerful chairman of the budget-writing House Appropriations Committee, is airing a 30-second ad showing him at work as a pharmacist.
“Chris Jones opened Bennet’s Creek Pharmacy, offering quality, affordable health care,” the narrator says. “That’s why he led the fight to expand Medicaid and improve our mental health system.”
The ad shifts to L.D. Britt, a surgeon and professor at Eastern Virginia Medical School. “Chris Jones - to get expansion, that is a major accomplishment,” he says.The screen flashes: ‘CHRIS JONES EXPANDED MEDICAID for 400,000 VIRGINIANS.”
The state Democratic party, in an Aug. 20 news release, denounced Jones’ ad as “a craven attempt to mislead his constituents.” The Democrats said Jones spent years “fighting tooth and nail to deny thousands of people in his community access to affordable health care.”
So we fact-checked Jones’ claim that he led the expansion fight and found that its accuracy varies, depending on the year.
Jones’ was a point man in a 2018 bipartisan compromise that allowed Medicaid to cover more than 400,000 additional low-income Virginians. But his ad doesn’t say that from 2013 to 2017, he was a leader in blocking expansion.
The roles Jones and other legislators played in Medicaid expansion could be a big issue this fall when all 140 General Assembly seats are on ballots. Democrats need to flip one seat in the Senate and two in the House to control of both chambers for the first time since 1999.
House Democrats may be aided by a 2018 judicial finding that some election districts had been racially gerrymandered. Court-ordered remapping has placed six Republicans incumbents - including Jones and Speaker Kirk Cox of Colonial Heights - in newly-shaped districts with a majority of Democratic voters.
Jones’ old district, which elected him 11 times, was 56% Republican, 44% Democratic, according to the non-partisan Virginia Public Access Project. His new district is 43% red, 57% blue. Jones is being challenged by Clint Jenkins, a realtor and local Democratic activist.
Let’s take a deeper look at Jones’ record on Medicaid expansion, starting with the early years.
Jones, 2013 to 2017
States were offered an option to expand their Medicaid programs to cover households earning up to 138% of the poverty line, beginning Jan. 1, 2014. The Affordable Care Act - or Obamacare - promised the federal government would pay all expansion costs at first, and never less than 90%.
Republican leaders - including outgoing Gov. Bob McDonnell and then-Speaker Bill Howell - declared their opposition in early 2013, saying they didn’t trust the federal pledge to pick up most of the expansion costs and that Virginia’s program was too inefficient to let grow. The state’s Medicaid costs during the previous decade had grown an average 9% a year, according to the Joint Subcommittee for Health and Human Resources.
Jones was on a team of budget negotiators that year that created a commission to find efficiencies in Virginia’s program that might open the door to future expansion.
Democrat Terry McAuliffe became governor in 2014 and made Medicaid expansion a top priority, accusing Republicans of turning down a federal windfall. Jones told reporters that January, “I don’t see any possibility of expansion this session,” and repeated his reforms-first mantra.
Jones undercut McAuliffe’s efforts to work expansion into the state budget and opposed it in a partisan floor vote. During a Feb. 20, 2014 floor speech, he said expansion should include a work requirement for able, adult Medicaid recipients. The Washington Post, in a June 23, 2014 article, identified Jones as “a leader in the fight against Medicaid expansion.”
McAuliffe tried again to expand Medicaid during the final three years of his term. Each time, Jones and his Appropriations Committee stripped it from the budget. “He knows we’re not going to give him that,” Jones said in Dec. 16, 2016.
The Richmond Times-Dispatch - in an April 6, 2017 article - reported Jones was on a team of five House Republican budget negotiators who “have steadfastly opposed Medicaid expansion.”
At the time, Republicans occupied 66 of 100 House seats. But they were rocked in 2017 elections when Democrats gained 15 seats and cut the GOP’s majority to one vote. Speaker Howell, a staunch opponent of expansion, didn’t run re-election. Democrat Ralph Northam was elected governor. In the changing political landscape, lawmakers were willing to deal.
With the blessings of Cox, the new speaker, Jones presented House Republicans with a budget option to expand Medicaid. It won enough support to pass the House with strong Democratic backing. The deal had two key components:
A work requirement for able-bodied adults on Medicaid. The Trump administration announced on Jan. 11, 2018 it would allow states to establish such programs, clearing uncertainty among Virginia Republicans.
Hospitals would pay the state’s expansion costs through a new provider tax, an idea proposed by McAuliffe in 2015 and conditionally backed that year by the Virginia Hospital and Healthcare Association. Hospitals concluded that, even with the tax, they would come out ahead because the expansion would cut their losses in treating uninsured patients.
The hospital tax eased GOP concerns that, if the federal government lowered its financial commitment to expansion, the state would be stuck with a large bill. Jones was also able to point to a report showing the efficiency commission had lowered state Medicaid costs by $43 million a year.
Jones fine-tuned the deal with Sen. Emmett Hanger, R-Augusta, the co-chairman of the Senate Finance Committee. Hanger withstood heavy criticism from Senate Majority Leader Tommy Norment, R-James City, and gained a few crucial Republican votes.
During a June 7 ceremony on Capitol steps, Northam signed the state budget that expanded Medicaid. He credited three Republicans: Jones, Cox and Hanger. Northam said he would save a signing pen for Jones, who didn’t attend the event because of work.
Jones says that - unlike many of his Republican colleagues - he never took a hardline position against expansion. He says he consistently said he’d be open to expansion if Virginia’s Medicaid was first streamlined, and that happened. The hospital tax was also key,
“It was always the question of how do we pay for this,” he said during an Aug. 23 interview.
Jones defended his campaign ad. “I was the chief architect of Medicaid expansion as it is today,” he said. “I was the point person in this. I got if off the floor.”
Addressing the Democratic Party’s criticism of his commercial, Jones said, “Maybe they would have preferred for me to say, ‘I led the fight to responsibly expand Medicaid.’”
In a TV ad, Jones claims he “led the fight to expand Medicaid” in Virginia.
Jones played an enormous role in the 2018 passage of expansion. He was a go-to man in building a bipartisan compromise on an issue that had divided Democrats and Republicans for years. Gov. Northam, a Democrat, has acknowledged Jones’ role.
But the fight to expand Medicaid began in 2013, and during the first four years, Jones spearheaded the Republican majority’s resistance. He opposed the expansion in a floor vote. As chairman of the House Appropriations Committee, he repeatedly helped strip expansion from proposed state budgets.
Jones credibly says he never shut the door on expansion and helped bring Medicaid efficiencies that made the expansion palatable to some Republicans. But it also can be said that Jones helped deny health insurance to 400,000 Virginians for four years. Twenty-nine states expanded their coverage before Virginia.
Jones’ ad claim addresses half of a complicated story. So we rate it Half True.
Chris Jones, TV ad, Aug. 19, 2019.
Interviews with Jones, Aug. 23 and Aug. 27, 2019.
Democratic Party of Virginia, News release, Aug. 22, 2019.
Virginia Public Access Project, House District 76, accessed Sept. 4, 2019.
The Washington Post, “National gun group launches campaign against suburban Republicans in Virginia,” Aug. 21, 2019.
Interview with Robert Vaughan, Staff director of the Virginia House Appropriations Committee, Aug. 28, 2019.
Interview with Susan Massart, Legislative financial analyst for the Virginia House Appropriations Committee, SAug. 28, 2019.
Email from Julian Walker, Vice president of communications for the Virginia Hospital and Healthcare Association, Sept. 4, 2019.
Joint Committee for Health and Human Resources, “Setting the Medicaid Target for the 2020-2022 Biennial Budget,“ Aug. 20, 2019.
The Washington Post, “McAuliffe to reappoint health official,” Dec. 19, 2013.
The Washington Post, “Virginia leader rankles the GOP,” Jan. 20, 2014.
The Washington Post, “Medicaid expansion savings are touted,” Jan. 23, 2014.
Legislative Information System, HB30, Item 4-14.00 #3h, Feb. 20, 2014.
The Washington Post, “Blinded by ideology,” Jan. 26, 2014.
The Washington Post, “House and Senate leaders at loggerheads over Medicaid expansion,” Feb. 20, 2019.